What is the difference between PhotoCAL and OptiCAL?

PhotoCAL is a feature-limited version of the acclaimed OptiCAL monitor calibration software. PhotoCAL is designed for beginners and photo enthusiasts and OptiCAL is targeted for advanced amateurs, professionals, animation studios, and prepress operations. OptiCAL provides many more features and facilities than PhotoCAL. Using the "Precision Mode" of OptiCAL can also produce a more accurate calibration than PhotoCAL. The two products are compared in the table on the right.
Spyder with PhotoCAL vs. SpyderPro with OptiCAL
Features Spyder SpyderPRO
Target End User Beginners and Photo Enthusiasts Advanced Amateurs and Professionals
Calibrates CRT and LCD Displays YES YES
Software PhotoCAL OptiCAL (3 licenses)
User Interface Wizard Wizard & Progressive Dialog
Choice of Gamma 2 Many, User-selectable
Choice of Color Temperature 2 Many, User-selectable
PreCAL Function YES YES
Custom Targets NO YES
Curve Manipulation NO YES
Colorimeter Tool NO YES
Reporting NO YES
Matching Different Monitors to Same Target NO YES
Precision Mode NO YES
1-Year Spyder Warranty YES YES
Free Technical Support YES YES
Free Software Upgrades YES YES

PhotoCAL is a wizard-based program that guides the user in a step-by-step process through each phase of the calibration. Instructions are given on each page. OptiCAL uses a dialog box software interface. While OptiCAL is not to difficult to use, PhotoCAL may be the better choice for technophobic users.

PhotoCAL provides the two most commonly used choices for gamma and colour temperature in the print and graphics industries. OptiCAL provides a very wide range of choices used in many different industries (animation, tv, video, etc) and also includes user-defined choices. Most beginners and enthusiasts will never need more than the PhotoCAL industry standard choices. We find that advanced users like to experiment with the OptiCAL settings for gamma and colour temperature to see the effect on displayed results. In many production environments, the ability to define custom targets - the combination of gamma and colour temperature - is a major benefit.

 


OptiCAL offers a "Curve Manipulation" function that is not available in PhotoCAL. This function graphically illustrates the gamma response curves of the monitor's red, green, and blue channels. Separate curves for the uncalibrated state, the calibrated state, and the ideal case are presented. The user can also manipulate these curves on a point-by-point basis to achieve almost any desired result. This is definitely an advanced feature that gives the user unlimited control, and is frankly, a lot of fun to use.

The OptiCAL "Colourimeter Tool" allows the user to select any colour or choose one from a colour picker, display it on screen, and measure the colour with the Spyder. This is an especially useful tool for web designers.

The OptiCAL "Precision Mode" of calibration provides numeric controls for setting the monitor's white and black luminance. This technique produces a more accurate calibration than PhotoCAL on CRT monitors. For LCD monitors, we recommend that users leave the Brightness and Contrast controls at the factory defaults.

Finally, if you are a scientist, colour geek, or a colour geek wannabe, OptiCAL provides a number of reports that provide colourimetric data. If you want to see the results of your calibration expressed in CIE values (like xyY, Lab, or Luv) - OptiCAL is your choice.

Return to Tips & Tricks

 

curve window in OptiCAL